spacestr

🔔 This profile hasn't been claimed yet. If this is your Nostr profile, you can claim it.

Edit
kleisli
Member since: 2023-02-23
kleisli
kleisli 3d

No, I do not believe we will ever attain large-scale, fault-tolerant quantum computers that deliver practical, exponential speedup on useful problems (e.g., breaking RSA-2048, simulating arbitrary molecules, or general optimization beyond what classical supercomputers + heuristics can do).Here is why I lean toward the skeptical side:The error-correction overhead is probably fatal in practice 1. The best physical two-qubit gate fidelities in 2025 are still around 99.9 % (superconducting) to 99.99 % (trapped ions). To get one logical qubit with error rate ~10⁻¹⁵ (needed for Shor’s algorithm on 2048-bit RSA) you need roughly 1,000–10,000 physical qubits per logical qubit under today’s best codes, and millions of physical qubits in total. Every doubling of logical-qubit count still multiplies the physical-qubit requirement by roughly 10× or more. There is no credible path from today’s ~100-qubit noisy devices to the required 10⁷–10⁹ near-perfect physical qubits without breakthroughs that violate known physics. 2. Decoherence and correlated errors are not just engineering problems Real systems have 1/f noise, cosmic-ray events, thermal fluctuations, and control crosstalk that produce strongly correlated errors across many qubits. Most theoretical fault-tolerance proofs assume independent, local, Markovian noise—conditions that are provably violated in every physical platform. When physicists model realistic correlated noise, the error-correction threshold collapses or disappears entirely ( Alicia & Kalai 2018–2024 papers, and many follow-ups). 3. The “exponentially small amplitudes” problem To factor a 2048-bit number with Shor’s algorithm, the quantum Fourier transform must resolve probability amplitudes on the order of 2⁻⁴⁰⁰⁰. That is smaller than one part in 10¹²⁰⁰. No physical instrument can distinguish a signal that small from zero, and no error-correction code can protect amplitudes that are smaller than the natural noise floor of the universe (thermal fluctuations, gravity-wave background, etc.). This is not a temporary engineering limit; it is a hard limit from basic quantum metrology and the holographic principle. 4. History of analog computing Every previous attempt to build scalable computers that rely on precise continuous parameters (analog computers in the 1940s–60s, optical computers in the 1980s–90s) eventually failed for exactly the same reason: noise and precision requirements scale exponentially with problem size. Quantum computers are the ultimate analog computers, and we have no example in the history of technology of an analog paradigm overtaking digital at scale. 5. What we will get instead We already have, and will continue to improve, noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices and quantum-inspired classical algorithms (tensor networks, QAOA-like heuristics, etc.) that give modest speedups on some chemistry and optimization problems—maybe 10–1000× in narrow cases. That is useful, but it is not the revolutionary exponential quantum advantage that was promised. In short: small quantum sensors, quantum networks, and specialized quantum simulators will become routine. But the dream of a universal, fault-tolerant quantum computer that obsoletes classical cryptography and simulation is, in my view, physically impossible—not just hard, not just 50 years away, but impossible with the laws of physics as we understand them.This is obviously a minority position in the current funding environment, but it is shared by a non-trivial number of serious physicists and complexity theorists (Gil Kalai, Mikhail Dyakonov, Stephen Wolfram, Leonid Levin, and others). The evidence has only strengthened in the skeptics’ direction since about 2019. - Grok #quantum #btc #cryptography #bitcoin

#quantum #btc #cryptography #bitcoin
kleisli
kleisli 2d

Don't forget all the mass control laws like the baliza 16, like tagging a pet to know where you are at all times.

kleisli
kleisli 21d

On this subject, has anyone heard of Peach? (https://peachbitcoin.com/index.html)

Welcome to kleisli spacestr profile!

About Me

Interests

  • No interests listed.

Videos

Music

My store is coming soon!

Friends